|
CHAPTER 24
"YOU ARE HERE"
In some of the rest areas of our great highway system in Texas,
a map of the state is provided. To help the traveler get his bearings,
an indicator points to the local spot with: "You are here."
The traveler may study the map, not only to see where he is, but
to see where he has come from, what he has passed on either side,
and what lies before him.
Some concerned researchers in the Church of Christ have made statistical
studies in recent years to try to locate our position on the progress
map. All have made discouraging observations. Some have expressed
alarm that our conversions have declined to, or below, zerogrowth
rate.
Learning that "we are here" far short of our destination,
we desire to know the cause and remedy for our lack of current
progress. Many helpful observations have been made. It is a complex
problem, so we must be suspicious of any simplistic causes or
cures which may be offered. There is a factor affecting our slow-down,
however, which seems to me to make our involved and expensive
evangelistic efforts ineffective. This cause is not usually pointed
out by our statisticians, possibly because it would hurt our self-image
to make such admissions about the Church of Christ. It would admit
that we have not followed our map closely enough and have traveled
some erroneous, muddy side roads.
The Stone-Campbell Movement, which sought to unite the Christians
in all the sects, was the most exciting thing to happen in religion
in early America. The plea to sweep away the complexity of creeds,
organizations, and traditions was something the common citizen
could grasp. It was a thrilling plea spread with great evangelistic
fervor. In the Nineteenth Century it became the fourth largest
religious group on America and was the largest indigenous movement.
But that was too good to be true.
Division diverted much of the attention and energy into in-fighting.
The unity plea was dulled, having become compromised and perverted.
The argumentation that brought and justified division brought
legalism. Legalism and doctrinal division developed together.
We can hardly have one without the other. Legalistic interpretations
foster divisions for they demand conformity, and divisions foster
legalistic interpretations to justify their existence.
The Church of Christ became a separate body and began to splinter
into other fellowships (a euphemism for sects). These divisions
began to proclaim that they were the one true church restored
and that unity could be had only by conformity with them. They
became exclusivists, claiming to be the only Christians. Now the
public was called upon, not just to decide against denominations
in general, but also to judge between different exclusivistic
groups, who each claimed to be the undenominational church.
In spite of the change of message, the division of the Movement,
and the divisive in-fightings, the Church of Christ regained momentum
in growth. How could this be, since the message had changed in
its appeal?
When a group has an unappealing, authoritarian, and demanding
message, it spreads in proportion to the militancy and fervor
of its adherents. The cults, Mormons, and Jehovah's Witnesses
are examples of what zeal can do. So, convinced that all people
must be in the Church of Christ in order to be saved, our zeal
made us the fastest growing group in America for a time in this
century.
Now there is a recession in the Church of Christ. A factor at
work among us which is quite different from those causing previous
slow-downs is: Our message has come to have an uncertain sound.
We have become an educated, sophisticated, uppermiddleclass
segment of our society. Both the preachers and the members are
beginning to see through our simplistic stance. Many are admitting
that we are not the only ones with a chance of heaven, that we
are a sectarian division, and that restoration of an extinct church
is invalid. They have replaced militant zeal with an irenic, non-judgmental
spirit.
These people are greatly frustrated because they are still held
in the congregational systems built upon the former concepts.
They cannot speak out without suffering recriminations within
the fellowship. Preachers dare not utter their more enlightened
thoughts lest they rock the boat and lose their positions. The
structures are still held in check by the exclusivistic thinkers.
So a stalemate has resulted from those conditions.
Being in this state of change, the Church of Christ is in its
adolescence, seeking its identity and direction. Some congregations
have been excited by this new enlightenment. Some are more ecumenical,
not sure now just who needs converting. Searching for direction,
some are emphasizing the servant church; some consider unstructured
fellowship and individuality as more important; others place the
Holy Spirit at the center; and some just want to preach Jesus,
whatever they mean by that.
In the final analysis, we have outgrown our simplistic message
and direction which we have confided in for much of this century.
Developing from that more childish era, we are in the midst of
the uncertainties of adolescence. Our aims and goals are not yet
clearly defined, so our message is somewhat ambiguous. At the
moment, doctrinal lessons are giving way to more Christ-centered
teaching along with much amateur psychology, personal dynamics,
cheerleading, and program building. We have not settled on a clear,
appealing message distinctive to the Church of Christ which we
can proclaim with enthusiasm.
And we may never settle on that distinctive message. Since there
is only one body, why should we seek for a message distinctive
to us - unless we want to continue being sectarian exclusivists?
The Lord's church will continue unshaken. The Church of Christ
segment of it needs to study the map, see where we are, and determine
what change in route is in order.
 
|